| JOHNNY's First-Class Team 2 | 416 | 94 | 369 | 69 | .267 |
| Bullwinkle's Peabody Team | 387 | 93 | 319 | 69 | .246 |
| Tret Titans | 425 | 120 | 383 | 63 | .264 |
| Jordan's World-Class Team | 376 | 100 | 363 | 74 | .238 |
| Needs more arms in the bullpen | 399 | 105 | 429 | 93 | .257 |
| Chris's Champion Team | 383 | 94 | 306 | 82 | .276 |
| 1st Pick | 354 | 90 | 319 | 64 | .245 |
| Trevaughn's Terrific Team | 391 | 101 | 386 | 76 | .250 |
| Madness | 384 | 81 | 346 | 77 | .255 |
| Deep in the Hole | 386 | 140 | 413 | 26 | .257 |
| steve's Fabulous Team | 321 | 103 | 359 | 42 | .237 |
| johnathan's Terrific Team | 354 | 108 | 356 | 44 | .243 |
