| Steve's Dandy Team | 378 | 101 | 381 | 53 | .264 |
| Gi Joe | 424 | 135 | 425 | 85 | .251 |
| Joseph's Crazy Team | 378 | 122 | 369 | 64 | .234 |
| Matt's Mind-Blowing Team | 421 | 122 | 423 | 50 | .259 |
| Around the Horn | 440 | 97 | 402 | 112 | .254 |
| Beginner's Luck Baseball Club | 369 | 86 | 305 | 53 | .266 |
| Gregory's Groovy Team | 334 | 93 | 343 | 34 | .245 |
| Judah Lions | 398 | 88 | 316 | 69 | .229 |
| Corina's Champion Team | 311 | 81 | 301 | 39 | .264 |
| Cody + Beau | 377 | 85 | 340 | 62 | .250 |
| Benson Bunnies | 429 | 109 | 417 | 57 | .258 |
| Eddy's Extraordinary Team | 383 | 111 | 376 | 88 | .233 |
